Coilover advantages/disadvantages
#1
Evolving Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Bay Area
Posts: 461
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Coilover advantages/disadvantages
I've been looking around for a set of coilovers. Aside from spring rates and dampening adjustment, the items I see that are advertised most are monotube/twintube shock bodies and rubber/pillow ball upper mounts. Can someone please kindly elaborate on the differences between these items, and the effects it will have on the dynamics of the car, as well as ride quality, noise, etc?
Also, if anyone has any opinions on what to get, that would be welcomed. I am looking for a set that will be comfortable to drive on daily but good enough for some occasional track duty. The two sets I've been most interested in are the HKS Hipermax IIIs (for features) and the BC Racing coilovers (for value). Thanks in advance!
Also, if anyone has any opinions on what to get, that would be welcomed. I am looking for a set that will be comfortable to drive on daily but good enough for some occasional track duty. The two sets I've been most interested in are the HKS Hipermax IIIs (for features) and the BC Racing coilovers (for value). Thanks in advance!
Last edited by wongck; Dec 8, 2008 at 12:15 PM.
#5
Evolved Member
iTrader: (16)
coil overs disadvatige , if they dont set up right you might be better with the stock suspension.
Thats about it.
Of course i'm talking about at least a good quality coilovers.
I cant really recall other disadvantage vs the factory ones. They are just simply better.
Maybe another one ... they cost more
If you are not racing then they are over kill, period.
If you go for looks then the good choice of springs are better for you.
Thats about it.
Of course i'm talking about at least a good quality coilovers.
I cant really recall other disadvantage vs the factory ones. They are just simply better.
Maybe another one ... they cost more
If you are not racing then they are over kill, period.
If you go for looks then the good choice of springs are better for you.
#6
In case anyone is cost conscious. I'm selling a set of .9" WORKS springs here:
https://www.evolutionm.net/forums/sh...04#post6447904
https://www.evolutionm.net/forums/sh...04#post6447904
#7
Former Sponsor
iTrader: (35)
There's a long thread somewhere in here with a long debate. What it really boils down to FOR ME is this:
Coilovers are overkill for a lot of people. They can be set-up wrong, or they can just plain be crappy coilovers with a pretty anodized finish and too many "features" that don't actually do anything. They can be fantastic as well, and ride better then stock, handle amazing at the track or auto-x, and last a long time. You need to pay a little more for those coilovers though and it helps to buy them from a trusted suspension shop that can help you set them up or do it for you. Robi is a great example of this and there are a few other places around that do this.
With a good strut + spring set-up, you can go pretty far too. Good ride quality, good handling, and they're cheap and easy to set-up. The CRUCIAL elements are that you do not lower the car too much. Handling and ride quality go out the door fast when this happens. Suspension travel is king.
So a good coilover is a bit better then a good strut + spring set-up IMO with these cars....but those start at $2k. On the lesser expensive side of things, I'd rather a good set of springs and struts (maybe add swaybars) then settling on a coilover based on price. That's just me. I'd urge you to go for rides with people near you to get an idea....so many people throw out terms on the net like "rides great," "handles like it's on rails," or "best suspension ever!" when they haven't really been on anything else. All this stuff is so subjective.
From looking at spring rates and drops, the Swifts appear to be the best springs out there for the X (but i wish Works would release there's so we could compare).
- Andrew
Coilovers are overkill for a lot of people. They can be set-up wrong, or they can just plain be crappy coilovers with a pretty anodized finish and too many "features" that don't actually do anything. They can be fantastic as well, and ride better then stock, handle amazing at the track or auto-x, and last a long time. You need to pay a little more for those coilovers though and it helps to buy them from a trusted suspension shop that can help you set them up or do it for you. Robi is a great example of this and there are a few other places around that do this.
With a good strut + spring set-up, you can go pretty far too. Good ride quality, good handling, and they're cheap and easy to set-up. The CRUCIAL elements are that you do not lower the car too much. Handling and ride quality go out the door fast when this happens. Suspension travel is king.
So a good coilover is a bit better then a good strut + spring set-up IMO with these cars....but those start at $2k. On the lesser expensive side of things, I'd rather a good set of springs and struts (maybe add swaybars) then settling on a coilover based on price. That's just me. I'd urge you to go for rides with people near you to get an idea....so many people throw out terms on the net like "rides great," "handles like it's on rails," or "best suspension ever!" when they haven't really been on anything else. All this stuff is so subjective.
From looking at spring rates and drops, the Swifts appear to be the best springs out there for the X (but i wish Works would release there's so we could compare).
- Andrew
Trending Topics
#10
I tend to agree with GTWORX's advice - I would go further to reiterate that rarely (by simply purchasing a set of coilovers 'over the counter') would you be able to find a better balanced setup for street and track use than the stock setup for a car like the Evo X. This is coming from someone who has owned and extensively driven on 12 sets of coilovers (all reputable brands) in recent years on both street and track and found that 4 sets (through adjustments) proved to be genuine improvements.
My advice would be that you should define a clear objective as to why you dislike the stock suspension and then figure out the best solution and understand the respective trade offs. If there is a specific handling trait you dislike (e.g. lack of braking stability, low speed understeer at corner entry, high speed power oversteer at corner exit etc.) then it would make sense to invest in a set of quality coilovers with suitable adjustability. Prepare to spend upwards of $4K.
If it's mainly for looks, then it wouldn't really matter...
Best of luck,
J
My advice would be that you should define a clear objective as to why you dislike the stock suspension and then figure out the best solution and understand the respective trade offs. If there is a specific handling trait you dislike (e.g. lack of braking stability, low speed understeer at corner entry, high speed power oversteer at corner exit etc.) then it would make sense to invest in a set of quality coilovers with suitable adjustability. Prepare to spend upwards of $4K.
If it's mainly for looks, then it wouldn't really matter...
Best of luck,
J
#11
Evolved Member
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: DE
Posts: 2,193
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I tend to agree with GTWORX's advice - I would go further to reiterate that rarely (by simply purchasing a set of coilovers 'over the counter') would you be able to find a better balanced setup for street and track use than the stock setup for a car like the Evo X. This is coming from someone who has owned and extensively driven on 12 sets of coilovers (all reputable brands) in recent years on both street and track and found that 4 sets (through adjustments) proved to be genuine improvements.
My advice would be that you should define a clear objective as to why you dislike the stock suspension and then figure out the best solution and understand the respective trade offs. If there is a specific handling trait you dislike (e.g. lack of braking stability, low speed understeer at corner entry, high speed power oversteer at corner exit etc.) then it would make sense to invest in a set of quality coilovers with suitable adjustability. Prepare to spend upwards of $4K.
If it's mainly for looks, then it wouldn't really matter...
Best of luck,
J
My advice would be that you should define a clear objective as to why you dislike the stock suspension and then figure out the best solution and understand the respective trade offs. If there is a specific handling trait you dislike (e.g. lack of braking stability, low speed understeer at corner entry, high speed power oversteer at corner exit etc.) then it would make sense to invest in a set of quality coilovers with suitable adjustability. Prepare to spend upwards of $4K.
If it's mainly for looks, then it wouldn't really matter...
Best of luck,
J
#12
Evolved Member
iTrader: (16)
I tend to agree with GTWORX's advice - I would go further to reiterate that rarely (by simply purchasing a set of coilovers 'over the counter') would you be able to find a better balanced setup for street and track use than the stock setup for a car like the Evo X. This is coming from someone who has owned and extensively driven on 12 sets of coilovers (all reputable brands) in recent years on both street and track and found that 4 sets (through adjustments) proved to be genuine improvements.
My advice would be that you should define a clear objective as to why you dislike the stock suspension and then figure out the best solution and understand the respective trade offs. If there is a specific handling trait you dislike (e.g. lack of braking stability, low speed understeer at corner entry, high speed power oversteer at corner exit etc.) then it would make sense to invest in a set of quality coilovers with suitable adjustability. Prepare to spend upwards of $4K.
If it's mainly for looks, then it wouldn't really matter...
Best of luck,
J
My advice would be that you should define a clear objective as to why you dislike the stock suspension and then figure out the best solution and understand the respective trade offs. If there is a specific handling trait you dislike (e.g. lack of braking stability, low speed understeer at corner entry, high speed power oversteer at corner exit etc.) then it would make sense to invest in a set of quality coilovers with suitable adjustability. Prepare to spend upwards of $4K.
If it's mainly for looks, then it wouldn't really matter...
Best of luck,
J
i dont know who are you but this is awesome!
#13
Evolving Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Bay Area
Posts: 461
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I do appreciate the advice I've been getting, but my original post asked something very specific pertaining to design in different coilovers. Here is what I wanted to know more about:
1. Advantages/disadvantages of Monotube vs Twintube shock body
2. Advantages/disadvantages of Rubber upper mount vs pillowball upper mount
I've done some research and I have the general idea (in theory) what differences they make, but I would like to hear some feedback from people who might've had personal experience with a wide range of coilovers. Thanks in advance!
1. Advantages/disadvantages of Monotube vs Twintube shock body
2. Advantages/disadvantages of Rubber upper mount vs pillowball upper mount
I've done some research and I have the general idea (in theory) what differences they make, but I would like to hear some feedback from people who might've had personal experience with a wide range of coilovers. Thanks in advance!
#14
Former Sponsor
iTrader: (35)
Generally a twin tube will have better ride quality. Partially because of the stiction/friction inherent in a monotube and the lower gas pressures in the twin tube.
Monotubes generally are better for performance due to more fluid capacity and larger piston area (more damping control).
All this is of course debateable and you can exceptions to the "rules" if the valving is good enough....or if the valving sucks. Valving is key.
- Andrew
Monotubes generally are better for performance due to more fluid capacity and larger piston area (more damping control).
All this is of course debateable and you can exceptions to the "rules" if the valving is good enough....or if the valving sucks. Valving is key.
- Andrew
Pillowballs are a more direct connection, better feedback, less deflection....but can make some noise or add to harshness. Especially with low quality bearings. They can also wear out after time. Camber plates have a ton of advantages if you want the extra camber obviously.
- drew
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
ODUB
Evo Tires / Wheels / Brakes / Suspension
37
May 26, 2017 06:39 PM
EvoJustin
Evo Tires / Wheels / Brakes / Suspension
35
Jan 3, 2013 12:09 PM
PedroMartinez
EvoM New Member / FAQs / EvoM Rules
10
Jul 6, 2007 12:42 PM
Diesel
Evo Tires / Wheels / Brakes / Suspension
52
Dec 22, 2004 05:38 AM
2008, advantages, ball, coilover, coilovers, dampening, define, disadvantages, evo, long, mounts, pillow, set, suitable, suspension